Insights | Does Software Outsourcing Commoditize Humans?

Does Software Outsourcing Commoditize Humans?

By Andy Hilliard | January 7, 2015

Does_Software_Outsourcing_Commoditize_HumansDo websites like Tinder, Elance and 99designs cause the Commoditizing of Humans?

If commoditization occurs, I think it comes from the values of the buyer. You can use online dating and other types of online matching services as a more efficient way to meet critical business or personal needs. You can also use them if you are simply looking for cheap thrills or inconsequential shallow relationships, in business or your personal life.

Another article suggests that the secret to the Uber economy is wealth inequality, as if Uber created wealth inequality or promotes it. The article compares services like Uber to menial work carried out by the poor in India. Jobs like driving for Uber (or working in McDonalds) can be stepping stones to more lucrative and meaningful careers in western economies. There will always be wealth inequality in economies. The challenge for workers is to take advantage of opportunities for upward mobility. The article fails to point out that those opportunities are more limited in the overpopulated, caste-constrained culture and economy found in Mumbai.

These articles claim a destructive social order of "specialized" services converts human beings into commodities that reduces the value and meaning of work. But people are not a mere physical resource, a tool, a faceless commodity designated valuable only as a means toward better company profits and greater corporate political authority.

The value of a man or a woman cannot be only defined by skill-sets that are appropriate to current business necessities. When the task at hand is completed, the individual who performed that task is not tradable, replaceable, and even disposable. Yet in a commodity-driven society, individuality ceases to exist and people are indeed considered interchangeable.

Is that what happens when you outsource your software development?

Software Outsourcing Does Not Commoditize Developers

If you are under the false impression that outsourcing advances the commoditization of software developers, you overlook the value of collaborative development. Although some goals associated with the early years of outsourcing involved an effort to find cheaper offshore developers that could be treated as plug-compatible replacements to on-site software teams, in most cases the assumption that developers were commodities resulted in poor services, unreliable feedback, and unexpected losses in time and labor. Hiring cheap developers is not efficient outsourcing!

In fact it’s not outsourcing at all! Outsourcing is not about hiring a company to cut corners and demean their employees. It is about finding a partner company that will save you time and money while doing a better job at delivering a service than what you could do with your own non-commodity employees. Software outsourcing gives you an effective way of recruiting, training and retaining technical talent. Outsourcing companies cannot treat developers like commodities and deliver a superior software development service. Those that have tried have failed. And that’s what has given software outsourcing a bad rep.

More from Accelerance

September 18, 2020

Spotlight on Colombia: Thriving Software Development Outsourcing Industry

I’ve been to Colombia four times on business trips – twice as a client, working on projects with there; and most recently, after joining the company myself, introducing a new client to the...

July 29, 2020

Spotlight on Costa Rica: Central America's Calling Card

When it comes to work/life balance, Costa Rica gets it right. In this beautiful and peaceful country, a “work hard and play hard” approach to life is the perfect mix. If you’re heading over on a...

July 27, 2020

Spotlight on Uruguay: South America’s Best-Kept Secret

Uruguay may be the second-smallest country in South America, with a population of just 3.5 million, but it’s the leading software exporter per capita in the region. Lying between Argentina and...

Whitepapers

August 15, 2020

2020 Guide to Software Outsourcing Rates

Gain insight into the latest rates for software development outsourcing resources with our proprietary benchmarking guide that offers:

July 27, 2020

2020 Guide to Software Outsourcing in Latin America

Qualified software engineering teams are not easily found. 

September 17, 2019

What CTOs Need to Tell CFOs About Software Development Outsourcing

Alignment between your company’s CFO and IT strategy is significant to outsourcing software development

Tech leaders and CFOs need to speak the same language when selecting a software outsourcing...

How can we help you succeed?

We make outsourcing successful with innovative partner selection services and tailor-made consulting solutions to ensure your desired outcomes.

Let’s Get Started