Insights | My Programming Language Is Better Than Yours!

My Programming Language Is Better Than Yours!

By Andy Hilliard | December 18, 2012

Language matters. Which isn’t a surprise, really — even in that old Tower of Babel story, wasn’t it a surfeit of competing languages that somehow brought the tower build to a screeching halt?

What does surprise me though is how little time and consideration developers are willing to invest in choosing which programming language they should use to implement a software application. Too often, there seems to be some sort of default: “The CEO or CTO knows Java, so I guess that’s what we’ll use”; “PHP is good enough, so we’ll just use that”; “we’re a Microsoft shop, so we’re going to use dot net.”

Imagine my excitement then when I discovered that an objective study had been conducted by ISBSG to tell us which programming languages lead to programmers being more productive.

Unfortunately, the results don’t live up to the promise.

The study draws from a database comparing 6,000 different projects. It shows that Classic ASP, through the initial dot net implementation from Microsoft, is the most productive. After that comes Visual Basic, then Java, then a bunch of others.

But I couldn’t help thinking, “Wait, where’s PHP, where’s Ruby on Rails, where’s Python? What about niche-y languages like Scala or Erlang?” My initial feeling of excitement turned to disappointment when I realized the study didn’t really seem complete or part of the real world. For example, it lists PL/1 – and I don’t know anybody who still programs in PL/1.

I suspect what may have happened is that the study focused on key projects at large companies where those older languages have been used over a span of years.

But disappointments can be instructive too, can’t they?

In analyzing what’s lacking in the study, you realize maybe programming languages can’t be looked at in a vacuum. Maybe other elements of the software development process are more important than just what language you’re in: your ability to collaborate, say. Or your ability to quickly do iterations and focus on a few features at a time rather than having a really long development cycle.

I also think there are some languages that lend themselves more to a team approach than others – and this can affect productivity. Java, for example, and C++ – basically the compiled languages – enable you to have modules and libraries that can be shared more easily than, say, PHP. I actually know clients who have complained that it’s difficult for them to hire PHP programmers who can work in a team because so much of web development is done by just one or two programmers where there isn’t as much teamwork needed.

Who knows? If the study had taken into account the built-in code review and coding standards of languages like Java and C# — and process issues in general — maybe it might have felt more complete, maybe even useful.

Or maybe I’m just Babeling.

 

 

 

More from Accelerance

October 21, 2020

Spotlight on Ukraine: Software Development in Lviv, the Silicon Valley of Eastern Europe

Almost every city with a solid tech scene draws comparisons with Silicon Valley. The iconic California region is synonymous with a mature software industry, tech innovation and growth, a superior...

October 15, 2020

Spotlight on Hungary: The Swiss Watchmakers of Software Development

It’s not a word I often use, but the new outsourcing partner I came to visit in Budapest could definitely be described as boutique. In total, they have less than 50 software developers (the largest...

October 15, 2020

Spotlight on Romania: The Rise of Software Outsourcing in Transylvania

When US company Fitbit opened its largest European research and development center in Bucharest in 2017, it really put the Romanian capital on the map. 

Whitepapers

September 25, 2020

2020 Guide to Outsourcing in Eastern & Central Europe

Learn About the Key Advantages to Outsourcing in Eastern & Central Europe:

August 15, 2020

2020 Guide to Software Outsourcing Rates

Gain insight into the latest rates for software development outsourcing resources with our proprietary benchmarking guide that offers:

July 27, 2020

2020 Guide to Software Outsourcing in Latin America

Qualified software engineering teams are not easily found. 

How can we help you succeed?

We make outsourcing successful with innovative partner selection services and tailor-made consulting solutions to ensure your desired outcomes.

Let’s Get Started